I was inspired by Dave Wainwright’s question regarding Georgia. Back in 2001 Georgia went 16-14 and was an eight seed.
Jerry was fully aware of this rare exception:
Indeed, their schedule was absolutely brutal. They earned their inclusion in the tournament, although I’m not sold on their seeding. St. Joseph’s got a #9 seed, which seems nuts in retrospect. Tennessee getting an #8 seed looks odd as well. Georgia’s inclusion over Cal Irvine caused some consternation out West:
http://articles.latimes.com/2001/mar/20/sports/sp-40254
Whole I agree Irvine belonged, Oklahoma State and Missouri are the teams I would have cut first, in favor of Southern Miss and Cal Irvine. After that, Alabama over #6 seed Notre Dame would have been fair. Yes, my third most deserving team left out would end up replacing a #6 seed. Things were odd back then.
In any event, Georgia was a rare exception. They merited inclusion, but that doesn’t mean another 16-14 team will get in any time soon.
(Note: The Pythags were generated with the Sagarin ratings)
Rank |
School |
WAB |
Pythag |
Seed |
1 |
Duke |
10.89 |
97.90% |
1 |
2 |
Stanford |
8.99 |
96.86% |
1 |
3 |
North Carolina |
7.64 |
93.46% |
2 |
4 |
Illinois |
6.96 |
95.06% |
1 |
5 |
Michigan St. |
6.78 |
95.94% |
1 |
6 |
Mississippi |
5.77 |
89.50% |
3 |
7 |
Kentucky |
5.57 |
92.89% |
2 |
8 |
Arizona |
5.52 |
95.88% |
2 |
9 |
Florida |
5.04 |
92.76% |
3 |
10 |
Boston College |
4.87 |
91.57% |
3 |
11 |
Kansas |
4.63 |
92.65% |
4 |
12 |
Oklahoma |
4.46 |
88.83% |
4 |
13 |
UCLA |
4.42 |
90.81% |
4 |
14 |
Iowa St. |
4.34 |
89.15% |
2 |
15 |
Texas |
4.20 |
87.36% |
6 |
16 |
Tennessee |
3.39 |
88.01% |
8 |
17 |
Maryland |
3.05 |
93.51% |
3 |
18 |
Wisconsin |
3.02 |
87.73% |
6 |
19 |
St. Joseph’s PA |
2.92 |
87.30% |
9 |
20 |
Virginia |
2.76 |
89.66% |
5 |
21 |
Wake Forest |
2.66 |
90.12% |
7 |
22 |
Indiana |
2.64 |
88.75% |
4 |
23 |
Iowa |
2.42 |
86.22% |
7 |
24 |
Southern California |
2.06 |
89.69% |
6 |
25 |
Fresno St. |
2.02 |
87.57% |
9 |
26 |
Syracuse |
1.99 |
82.73% |
5 |
27 |
Penn St. |
1.93 |
85.65% |
7 |
28 |
Ohio St. |
1.74 |
85.74% |
5 |
29 |
Cincinnati |
1.67 |
87.82% |
5 |
30 |
Xavier OH |
1.54 |
85.05% |
11 |
31 |
California |
1.54 |
86.64% |
8 |
32 |
Georgia Tech |
1.43 |
84.26% |
8 |
33 |
Georgia St. |
1.07 |
78.35% |
11 |
34 |
Arkansas |
0.88 |
85.21% |
7 |
35 |
Southern Mississippi |
0.82 |
82.35% |
Null |
36 |
Cal Irvine |
0.75 |
67.88% |
Null |
37 |
Creighton |
0.73 |
83.65% |
10 |
38 |
Georgetown |
0.66 |
84.93% |
10 |
39 |
Charlotte |
0.64 |
85.59% |
9 |
40 |
Temple |
0.64 |
88.48% |
11 |
41 |
Alabama |
0.58 |
84.82% |
Null |
42 |
Butler |
0.55 |
85.60% |
10 |
43 |
Georgia |
0.54 |
82.81% |
8 |
44 |
Gonzaga |
0.42 |
83.61% |
12 |
45 |
Hofstra |
0.30 |
77.26% |
13 |
46 |
Brigham Young |
0.18 |
80.95% |
12 |
47 |
Providence |
0.18 |
83.99% |
10 |
48 |
Notre Dame |
0.00 |
84.54% |
6 |
49 |
Utah St. |
-0.02 |
81.81% |
12 |
50 |
Texas El Paso |
-0.04 |
77.02% |
Null |
51 |
Missouri |
-0.36 |
80.87% |
9 |
52 |
Richmond |
-0.40 |
78.88% |
Null |
53 |
Southern Utah |
-0.46 |
70.91% |
14 |
54 |
Pepperdine |
-0.52 |
79.60% |
Null |
55 |
Oklahoma St. |
-0.74 |
79.09% |
11 |
56 |
Villanova |
-0.95 |
75.63% |
Null |
57 |
Western Kentucky |
-1.01 |
76.99% |
14 |
58 |
Wyoming |
-1.13 |
76.38% |
Null |
59 |
Mississippi St. |
-1.15 |
81.83% |
Null |
60 |
Dayton |
-1.31 |
77.67% |
Null |
61 |
Tulsa |
-1.40 |
83.90% |
Null |
62 |
Minnesota |
-1.55 |
75.09% |
Null |
63 |
Connecticut |
-1.63 |
77.28% |
Null |
64 |
St. Bonaventure |
-1.80 |
74.99% |
Null |
65 |
Illinois St. |
-1.95 |
70.14% |
Null |
66 |
Auburn |
-2.10 |
77.88% |
Null |
67 |
Lipscomb |
-2.20 |
43.25% |
Null |
68 |
South Carolina |
-2.21 |
77.26% |
Null |
69 |
Central Michigan |
-2.24 |
61.58% |
Null |
70 |
Purdue |
-2.28 |
80.89% |
Null |
71 |
Kent St. |
-2.31 |
76.58% |
13 |
72 |
Detroit |
-2.32 |
78.00% |
Null |
73 |
Valparaiso |
-2.39 |
69.48% |
Null |
74 |
Utah |
-2.44 |
76.97% |
Null |
75 |
College of Charleston |
-2.49 |
64.54% |
Null |
76 |
Cal St. Northridge |
-2.54 |
72.30% |
13 |
77 |
Massachusetts |
-2.65 |
76.26% |
Null |
78 |
Baylor |
-2.71 |
70.14% |
Null |
79 |
West Virginia |
-2.78 |
66.65% |
Null |
80 |
Toledo |
-2.82 |
73.17% |
Null |
81 |
Holy Cross |
-2.84 |
62.16% |
15 |
82 |
Miami FL |
-2.99 |
72.50% |
Null |
83 |
South Florida |
-3.05 |
77.28% |
Null |
84 |
Santa Clara |
-3.06 |
66.25% |
Null |
85 |
TCU |
-3.09 |
77.02% |
Null |
86 |
New Mexico |
-3.14 |
71.47% |
Null |
87 |
Pittsburgh |
-3.14 |
71.97% |
Null |
88 |
Marshall |
-3.16 |
68.39% |
Null |
89 |
Hawaii |
-3.22 |
70.17% |
12 |
90 |
Southern Methodist |
-3.29 |
72.82% |
Null |
91 |
Ohio |
-3.38 |
69.50% |
Null |
92 |
Hampton |
-3.38 |
56.38% |
15 |
93 |
Eastern Illinois |
-3.39 |
63.98% |
15 |
94 |
South Alabama |
-3.46 |
64.07% |
Null |
95 |
Vanderbilt |
-3.48 |
71.61% |
Null |
96 |
NC Wilmington |
-3.49 |
65.26% |
Null |
97 |
North Carolina St. |
-3.50 |
74.86% |
Null |
98 |
Memphis |
-3.53 |
80.18% |
Null |
99 |
Tennessee Tech |
-3.57 |
61.45% |
Null |
100 |
Seton Hall |
-3.58 |
69.48% |
Null |
101 |
Oregon |
-3.59 |
73.15% |
Null |
102 |
Indiana St. |
-3.71 |
71.83% |
13 |
103 |
Austin Peay |
-3.93 |
63.03% |
Null |
104 |
McNeese St. |
-4.10 |
59.52% |
Null |
105 |
St. John’s NY |
-4.15 |
72.69% |
Null |
106 |
Bradley |
-4.16 |
61.97% |
Null |
107 |
Gardner Webb |
-4.18 |
31.05% |
Null |
108 |
Marquette |
-4.28 |
68.86% |
Null |
109 |
St. Louis |
-4.30 |
74.39% |
Null |
110 |
Delaware |
-4.48 |
63.44% |
Null |
111 |
Wright St. |
-4.66 |
58.92% |
Null |
112 |
George Mason |
-4.67 |
68.71% |
14 |
113 |
UAB |
-4.75 |
69.97% |
Null |
114 |
Savannah St. |
-4.81 |
3.72% |
Null |
115 |
UNLV |
-4.82 |
64.01% |
Null |
116 |
Cleveland St. |
-4.89 |
62.77% |
Null |
117 |
LSU |
-4.91 |
69.56% |
Null |
118 |
Arizona St. |
-4.91 |
72.85% |
Null |
119 |
Princeton |
-4.95 |
51.66% |
15 |
120 |
Wisconsin Milwaukee |
-5.28 |
64.67% |
Null |
121 |
Colorado |
-5.28 |
72.08% |
Null |
122 |
Iona |
-5.30 |
59.75% |
14 |
123 |
Alabama St. |
-5.57 |
38.81% |
16 |
124 |
Binghamton |
-5.61 |
42.38% |
Null |
125 |
Murray St. |
-5.68 |
58.12% |
Null |
126 |
Michigan |
-5.74 |
56.55% |
Null |
127 |
Nebraska |
-5.76 |
69.91% |
Null |
128 |
Eastern Washington |
-5.77 |
53.43% |
Null |
129 |
Washington St. |
-5.77 |
56.85% |
Null |
130 |
San Diego |
-5.78 |
64.83% |
Null |
131 |
Ball St. |
-5.82 |
58.59% |
Null |
132 |
Maine |
-5.88 |
49.57% |
Null |
133 |
Monmouth NJ |
-5.95 |
46.63% |
16 |
134 |
Mississippi Valley St. |
-5.95 |
34.99% |
Null |
135 |
Youngstown St. |
-5.96 |
47.25% |
Null |
136 |
Siena |
-5.96 |
56.62% |
Null |
137 |
Radford |
-6.04 |
40.98% |
Null |
138 |
Colorado St. |
-6.14 |
63.12% |
Null |
139 |
Canisius |
-6.15 |
51.45% |
Null |
140 |
San Jose St. |
-6.16 |
57.76% |
Null |
141 |
Arkansas Little Rock |
-6.17 |
53.20% |
Null |
142 |
Pacific |
-6.18 |
55.10% |
Null |
143 |
East Tennessee St. |
-6.25 |
47.93% |
Null |
144 |
Louisiana Lafayette |
-6.34 |
54.01% |
Null |
145 |
Troy St. |
-6.34 |
49.71% |
Null |
146 |
Long Beach St. |
-6.47 |
50.56% |
Null |
147 |
Stony Brook |
-6.47 |
32.93% |
Null |
148 |
Louisiana Tech |
-6.49 |
51.56% |
Null |
149 |
Southern Illinois |
-6.75 |
58.19% |
Null |
150 |
Kansas St. |
-6.76 |
60.11% |
Null |
151 |
Rutgers |
-6.84 |
62.51% |
Null |
152 |
NC Greensboro |
-6.88 |
44.29% |
16 |
153 |
George Washington |
-6.92 |
68.80% |
Null |
154 |
Jacksonville |
-6.95 |
40.94% |
Null |
155 |
Clemson |
-6.98 |
53.77% |
Null |
156 |
Navy |
-7.00 |
51.93% |
Null |
157 |
Boise St. |
-7.09 |
53.02% |
Null |
158 |
Northwestern |
-7.10 |
56.55% |
Null |
159 |
South Carolina St. |
-7.20 |
41.04% |
Null |
160 |
Miami OH |
-7.20 |
63.69% |
Null |
161 |
Bowling Green |
-7.21 |
55.71% |
Null |
162 |
San Diego St. |
-7.26 |
53.81% |
Null |
163 |
La Salle |
-7.37 |
57.99% |
Null |
164 |
Drexel |
-7.40 |
46.80% |
Null |
165 |
Arkansas St. |
-7.46 |
45.31% |
Null |
166 |
Alabama A&M |
-7.54 |
26.26% |
Null |
167 |
VA Commonwealth |
-7.55 |
54.90% |
Null |
168 |
St. Francis NY |
-7.56 |
39.66% |
Null |
169 |
New Orleans |
-7.59 |
46.77% |
Null |
170 |
DePaul |
-7.64 |
57.79% |
Null |
171 |
Louisville |
-7.65 |
58.66% |
Null |
172 |
Rider |
-7.66 |
45.07% |
Null |
173 |
Fordham |
-7.71 |
53.02% |
Null |
174 |
Rice |
-7.72 |
55.37% |
Null |
175 |
Northwestern St. |
-7.73 |
37.45% |
16 |
176 |
SE Missouri St. |
-7.75 |
47.11% |
Null |
177 |
MD Baltimore County |
-7.79 |
36.72% |
Null |
178 |
Marist |
-7.82 |
48.20% |
Null |
179 |
Niagara |
-7.83 |
43.45% |
Null |
180 |
Winthrop |
-7.86 |
42.68% |
16 |
181 |
Brown |
-7.89 |
34.00% |
Null |
182 |
Chattanooga |
-7.93 |
50.26% |
Null |
183 |
Stetson |
-8.25 |
42.07% |
Null |
184 |
Washington |
-8.30 |
46.12% |
Null |
185 |
Illinois Chicago |
-8.41 |
52.99% |
Null |
186 |
NC Asheville |
-8.50 |
30.64% |
Null |
187 |
Oregon St. |
-8.58 |
54.90% |
Null |
188 |
New Mexico St. |
-8.59 |
50.53% |
Null |
189 |
Florida St. |
-8.61 |
51.80% |
Null |
190 |
SW Missouri St. |
-8.71 |
51.86% |
Null |
191 |
Weber St. |
-8.71 |
44.12% |
Null |
192 |
The Citadel |
-8.79 |
34.18% |
Null |
193 |
Idaho St. |
-8.94 |
41.04% |
Null |
194 |
Akron |
-8.97 |
43.25% |
Null |
195 |
Cal Santa Barbara |
-9.00 |
41.87% |
Null |
196 |
Harvard |
-9.11 |
32.63% |
Null |
197 |
Samford |
-9.18 |
43.28% |
Null |
198 |
Evansville |
-9.21 |
47.62% |
Null |
199 |
East Carolina |
-9.22 |
44.33% |
Null |
200 |
Montana St. |
-9.22 |
43.25% |
Null |
201 |
Sam Houston St. |
-9.37 |
37.71% |
Null |
202 |
Boston University |
-9.39 |
38.75% |
Null |
203 |
Wisconsin Green Bay |
-9.39 |
45.31% |
Null |
204 |
Drake |
-9.70 |
47.38% |
Null |
205 |
Manhattan |
-9.73 |
47.08% |
Null |
206 |
Wagner |
-9.91 |
31.58% |
Null |
207 |
Alcorn St. |
-9.95 |
24.52% |
Null |
208 |
Texas Tech |
-9.96 |
43.15% |
Null |
209 |
Texas A&M Corpus Chris |
-9.96 |
32.69% |
Null |
210 |
Texas A&M |
-10.11 |
41.11% |
Null |
211 |
Northern Arizona |
-10.16 |
41.34% |
Null |
212 |
Mercer |
-10.19 |
32.99% |
Null |
213 |
Oakland |
-10.20 |
35.89% |
Null |
214 |
Nevada |
-10.25 |
48.07% |
Null |
215 |
Virginia Tech |
-10.32 |
33.08% |
Null |
216 |
Nicholls St. |
-10.39 |
28.39% |
Null |
217 |
Texas San Antonio |
-10.40 |
32.84% |
Null |
218 |
Wofford |
-10.40 |
37.42% |
Null |
219 |
Old Dominion |
-10.51 |
50.39% |
Null |
220 |
Bucknell |
-10.52 |
26.32% |
Null |
221 |
Coppin St. |
-10.53 |
26.72% |
Null |
222 |
Missouri Kansas City |
-10.68 |
41.24% |
Null |
223 |
Georgia Southern |
-10.71 |
37.10% |
Null |
224 |
Pennsylvania |
-10.75 |
40.61% |
Null |
225 |
Belmont |
-10.83 |
29.69% |
Null |
226 |
Houston |
-10.84 |
42.78% |
Null |
227 |
San Francisco |
-10.84 |
38.39% |
Null |
228 |
Morehead St. |
-10.91 |
32.45% |
Null |
229 |
Portland |
-10.92 |
31.52% |
Null |
230 |
Fairfield |
-11.05 |
35.89% |
Null |
231 |
James Madison |
-11.06 |
37.74% |
Null |
232 |
SW Texas St. |
-11.18 |
25.37% |
Null |
233 |
Texas Arlington |
-11.38 |
27.72% |
Null |
234 |
Columbia |
-11.40 |
22.89% |
Null |
235 |
Delaware St. |
-11.50 |
22.48% |
Null |
236 |
Fairleigh Dickinson |
-11.50 |
24.47% |
Null |
237 |
MD Eastern Shore |
-11.53 |
19.22% |
Null |
238 |
William & Mary |
-11.59 |
34.86% |
Null |
239 |
Colgate |
-11.62 |
24.27% |
Null |
240 |
Montana |
-11.63 |
30.99% |
Null |
241 |
Central Connecticut |
-11.63 |
25.76% |
Null |
242 |
Davidson |
-11.72 |
29.52% |
Null |
243 |
Cal Riverside |
-11.76 |
21.19% |
Null |
244 |
Texas Pan American |
-11.81 |
32.96% |
Null |
245 |
Norfolk St. |
-11.91 |
27.34% |
Null |
246 |
Tulane |
-11.95 |
32.06% |
Null |
247 |
Vermont |
-12.05 |
26.80% |
Null |
248 |
Louisiana Monroe |
-12.13 |
23.10% |
Null |
249 |
Furman |
-12.23 |
28.84% |
Null |
250 |
Tennessee Martin |
-12.33 |
26.77% |
Null |
251 |
Loyola Marymount |
-12.36 |
29.20% |
Null |
252 |
Duquesne |
-12.40 |
40.42% |
Null |
253 |
Wichita St. |
-12.41 |
39.53% |
Null |
254 |
Yale |
-12.52 |
25.19% |
Null |
255 |
Liberty |
-12.53 |
19.52% |
Null |
256 |
Long Island |
-12.56 |
17.85% |
Null |
257 |
Towson |
-12.60 |
26.18% |
Null |
258 |
Lehigh |
-12.69 |
24.32% |
Null |
259 |
Lafayette |
-12.77 |
26.37% |
Null |
260 |
IUPUI |
-13.01 |
32.21% |
Null |
261 |
Denver |
-13.15 |
27.37% |
Null |
262 |
Portland St. |
-13.17 |
25.11% |
Null |
263 |
North Carolina A&T |
-13.29 |
22.21% |
Null |
264 |
Grambling |
-13.35 |
10.39% |
Null |
265 |
Tennessee St. |
-13.40 |
32.00% |
Null |
266 |
Air Force |
-13.44 |
32.99% |
Null |
267 |
Morris Brown |
-13.49 |
11.93% |
Null |
268 |
Centenary |
-13.49 |
19.11% |
Null |
269 |
Northeastern |
-13.51 |
24.85% |
Null |
270 |
Eastern Kentucky |
-13.66 |
16.20% |
Null |
271 |
Southern |
-13.67 |
13.49% |
Null |
272 |
Loyola Chicago |
-13.69 |
29.57% |
Null |
273 |
Rhode Island |
-13.73 |
30.12% |
Null |
274 |
Howard |
-13.76 |
13.78% |
Null |
275 |
Oral Roberts |
-13.91 |
21.67% |
Null |
276 |
Stephen F. Austin |
-14.13 |
19.43% |
Null |
277 |
Jacksonville St. |
-14.19 |
20.00% |
Null |
278 |
Cal Poly |
-14.30 |
24.83% |
Null |
279 |
American |
-14.52 |
23.23% |
Null |
280 |
Western Michigan |
-14.57 |
25.89% |
Null |
281 |
Florida International |
-14.77 |
22.02% |
Null |
282 |
Lamar |
-14.79 |
15.55% |
Null |
283 |
St. Francis PA |
-14.92 |
15.37% |
Null |
284 |
Charleston Southern |
-15.12 |
14.03% |
Null |
285 |
Coastal Carolina |
-15.18 |
15.75% |
Null |
286 |
VMI |
-15.23 |
16.98% |
Null |
287 |
Bethune Cookman |
-15.23 |
13.49% |
Null |
288 |
Appalachian St. |
-15.26 |
20.15% |
Null |
289 |
Idaho |
-15.30 |
17.49% |
Null |
290 |
Army |
-15.36 |
12.63% |
Null |
291 |
Dartmouth |
-15.55 |
14.18% |
Null |
292 |
New Hampshire |
-15.57 |
17.87% |
Null |
293 |
High Point |
-16.29 |
10.39% |
Null |
294 |
SE Louisiana |
-16.32 |
17.47% |
Null |
295 |
Northern Iowa |
-16.38 |
28.75% |
Null |
296 |
Northern Illinois |
-16.49 |
15.94% |
Null |
297 |
Elon |
-16.50 |
11.49% |
Null |
298 |
Middle Tennessee St. |
-16.62 |
14.43% |
Null |
299 |
Cornell |
-16.80 |
13.49% |
Null |
300 |
Campbell |
-16.87 |
13.46% |
Null |
301 |
Chicago St. |
-17.03 |
13.67% |
Null |
302 |
Buffalo |
-17.23 |
20.04% |
Null |
303 |
North Texas |
-17.24 |
10.13% |
Null |
304 |
Sacred Heart |
-17.32 |
9.18% |
Null |
305 |
Western Illinois |
-17.34 |
16.61% |
Null |
306 |
Cal St. Fullerton |
-17.47 |
15.34% |
Null |
307 |
Texas Southern |
-17.65 |
7.69% |
Null |
308 |
Cal St. Sacramento |
-17.65 |
11.73% |
Null |
309 |
Robert Morris |
-17.78 |
12.12% |
Null |
310 |
Quinnipiac |
-17.87 |
9.58% |
Null |
311 |
Central Florida |
-17.91 |
22.26% |
Null |
312 |
Mount St. Mary’s |
-17.93 |
10.40% |
Null |
313 |
Prairie View A&M |
-18.13 |
5.87% |
Null |
314 |
St. Peter’s |
-18.17 |
14.40% |
Null |
315 |
Loyola MD |
-18.25 |
16.50% |
Null |
316 |
Florida A&M |
-18.30 |
8.24% |
Null |
317 |
Jackson St. |
-18.33 |
10.88% |
Null |
318 |
Florida Atlantic |
-18.38 |
15.21% |
Null |
319 |
Albany NY |
-18.53 |
8.20% |
Null |
320 |
Morgan St. |
-18.71 |
12.58% |
Null |
321 |
Eastern Michigan |
-18.87 |
14.09% |
Null |
322 |
St. Mary’s CA |
-19.76 |
8.27% |
Null |
323 |
Western Carolina |
-19.81 |
15.02% |
Null |
324 |
Hartford |
-19.83 |
10.80% |
Null |
325 |
Arkansas Pine Bluff |
-19.92 |
3.23% |
Null |